Buy and Sell debt portfolios online

How to Collect a Judgement from a Business: Focusing on LLCs

Fact checked
Read time:
3
min

This text has undergone thorough fact-checking to ensure accuracy and reliability. All information presented is backed by verified sources and reputable data. By adhering to stringent fact-checking standards, we aim to provide you with reliable and trustworthy content. You can trust the information presented here to make informed decisions with confidence.

Table of contents
Key takeaways:
Collecting a judgment from a Limited Liability Company (LLC) can be a complex process, often requiring careful navigation of legal procedures. Typically, this involves identifying the LLC's assets, securing a court order, and working with a sheriff or marshal to execute the judgment through means such as seizing assets or garnishing income.

Collecting a court judgment from a Limited Liability Company (LLC) to collect money can be a complex process, often requiring careful navigation of legal procedures. Typically, this involves identifying the LLC’s assets, securing a court order, and working with a sheriff or marshal to execute the judgment through means such as seizing assets or garnishing income. Collecting a court judgment from a limited liability company (LLC) can be complex, requiring an understanding of legal processes such as judgment liens. The judgment creditor must grasp business structures and jurisdiction to effectively claim from the judgment debtor. The process of setting up a limited liability company involves steps like serving interrogatories, examining the business structure via the operating agreement, identifying membership interests under the jurisdiction, and consulting with attorneys. These tasks aim to uncover the business assets of the judgment debtor that can satisfy the judgment liens, as decided by the judgment creditor and bankruptcy courts. Whether dealing with single member or multiple members LLCs, each presents unique challenges in judgment collection, particularly concerning membership interests. Personal creditors may pose a threat to a debtor business. Consultation with an attorney is often necessary. This post provides a concise overview of how to navigate the process of rights attachment, form completion, and protection effectively, including how to collect a judgment from a business.

Understanding the Judgment Collection Process

State Laws Role

Each state has its own rules. These garnishment rules guide how courts, acting as judgment creditors, collect payment from judgment debtors under the law, impacting the timing and methods of collection efforts, including placing liens on the debtor's property. For example, in some states, a garnishment order from courts can be placed on the debtor’s property by personal creditors for payment, resulting in a judgment lien.

LLCs Non-compliance Consequences

LLCs must follow court orders. If a debtor fails to comply with court orders, they face serious consequences. Owners could lose their rights to do business in that jurisdiction if the court, enforcing the law, identifies them as a debtor.

Collection Process Hurdles

Collecting a judgement isn't always smooth sailing. Sometimes, legal obstacles pop up that slow things down. For instance, garnishment laws vary and can complicate matters.

‍

Locating Assets of the Judgment Debtor

Locating the assets of a judgment debtor is a critical step in the judgment collection process. Judgment creditors need to identify the debtor’s assets to determine the best course of action for collecting the debt. Judgment creditors can obtain a levy against a debtor's bank account, which allows for direct withdrawals to satisfy the debt. This can involve searching public records, conducting investigations, and using various tools and resources to locate the debtor’s assets.

Some common assets that judgment creditors may look for include:

  • Bank accounts: Judgment creditors can search for the debtor’s bank accounts to determine if they have sufficient funds to pay the debt.
  • Real property: The creditor can search for real property owned by the debtor, such as homes or commercial buildings, to determine if they can place a lien on the property.
  • Personal property: The creditor can search for personal property owned by the debtor, such as vehicles or equipment, to determine if they can seize the property to satisfy the debt.
  • Business assets: If the debtor is a business, the creditor can search for business assets, such as equipment or inventory, to determine if they can seize the assets to satisfy the debt.

Judgment creditors can use various tools and resources to locate the debtor’s assets, including:

  • Public records: The creditor can search public records, such as property records or court records, to locate the debtor’s assets.
  • Asset search services: The creditor can use asset search services, such as private investigators or asset search companies, to locate the debtor’s assets.
  • Online databases: The creditor can use online databases, such as people search websites or asset search websites, to locate the debtor’s assets.

By locating the assets of the judgment debtor, creditors can determine the best course of action for collecting the debt and increase their chances of recovering their losses.

Securing Repayment

Securing repayment from a judgment debtor can be a challenging and time-consuming process. However, there are several steps that a judgment creditor can take to increase the chances of collecting the debt. One of the most effective ways to secure repayment is to file a judgment lien against the debtor’s property. This can include real estate, personal property, or business assets. A judgment lien gives the creditor a legal claim to the property and can prevent the debtor from selling or transferring it until the debt is paid.

Another way to secure repayment is to garnish the debtor’s wages or bank accounts. This involves obtaining a court order that requires the debtor’s employer or bank to withhold a portion of their wages or account balance and pay it directly to the creditor. Wage garnishment and bank levies can be effective ways to collect a judgment, but they can also be time-consuming and may require additional court proceedings.

In some cases, a judgment creditor may also consider hiring a collection agency to help collect the debt. Collection agencies specialize in debt collection and can often negotiate with the debtor to reach a settlement or payment plan. However, it’s essential to carefully research and select a reputable collection agency to ensure that they are acting in the creditor’s best interests.

‍

What are Charging Orders

Charging orders are court orders. They help creditors collect debts from LLCs.

For example, if a judgment debtor's business owes you money, a charging order can enforce payment to you as the judgment creditor, despite personal creditors.

Using Charging Orders for Debt Collection

Charging orders can be useful tools in debt collection. Charging orders can be compared to wage garnishment, which is used to collect debts from an individual's income. They allow creditors to go after an LLC’s distributions.

This implies that any payment the LLC, as a business debtor, disburses, the personal creditors of the owners get first dibs on it. But remember, this doesn’t include salary payments to members.

For instance, if a business debtor such as an LLC makes a profit and decides to distribute some of it as payment among its members with a membership interest, the personal creditors with a charging order will get paid before anyone else does.

Limitations of Charging Orders

However, charging orders have limitations too. They only apply to an LLC’s distributions.

This implies that if the debtor LLC doesn’t make any payment distributions or compensates its members through salaries instead of membership interest, the personal creditors might not receive anything.

Furthermore, certain states restrict the application of charging orders against single-member LLCs, impacting membership interest, creditors, owners, and potentially benefiting a judgment creditor. In these cases, creditors, acting as the charging party, may need to find other ways to enforce their rights and collect their debts from the debtor's property, ensuring payment.

Using a charging order to secure payment can be complex for a creditor and might require hiring a collection agency or lawyer, which could result in additional fees. This process can affect both the debtor and creditors’ rights, necessitating careful consideration.

For example, if a debtor’s LLC has multiple bank accounts or operates in different states, collecting payment through a charging order from judgment creditors could become complicated and costly.

Understanding LLC's Personal Liability Shields

Limited Liability Companies (LLCs), where members enjoy rights, have a feature known as a personal liability shield protecting against judgment creditors. This shield protects the personal assets of a member within the LLC from debtor and creditors' interest. It's like having a big, strong wall around your stuff, a member's order of interest in states.

Impact on Judgment Debtor's Assets Collections

Now, here's the kicker. Because of these shields, creditors collecting a judgment from a debtor member of an LLC can face interest-related challenges. Consider the interest of trying to get past that big wall, as a member, we discussed earlier in order to tackle the debtor issue. Not so easy, right?

‍

Navigating Around Liability Shields

But don't worry! There are ways to navigate around these shields. Here are some steps you might take:

  1. Pierce the corporate veil: This means demonstrating that the LLC is not separate from its owner(s), thereby making them a potential creditor, subject to interest. If you can generate interest from the creditor, you could reach their personal assets.
  2. Claim statutory exemptions: Some property is exempt from collection by a creditor under state law, regardless of interest. You may need to claim these exemptions.
  3. Target non-exempt property: If there's property that isn't protected by statutory exemptions, it might be up for grabs by the creditor.

Remember though, every creditor case is different and what works for one creditor might not work for another.

Legal Tools at Your Disposal

When a court rules in your favor against an LLC, you, as the creditor, have legal tools to collect the judgement. The court clerk plays a crucial role in issuing the necessary documents for the sheriff’s levy. One common method is a sheriff’s levy.

A sheriff can seize and sell debtor business assets. This helps pay off the judgement.

Challenges with LLCs

Collecting from LLCs isn't always easy though. There are laws that protect member LLCs and their personal assets from creditors.

For instance, some states don't allow creditors to seize personal assets unless it's proven that the business owners used the company for fraud.

Timing and Strategy Matter for Wage Garnishment

Enforcing judgments require smart timing and strategy. Working with experienced attorneys can be beneficial.

Creditors know when to move fast or slow down depending on the case. For example, if a creditor's opposing party files bankruptcy, it may be better for the creditor to wait until after proceedings end.

‍

Necessary Actions Post Lawsuit

After you win a lawsuit, the work isn’t over. You need to collect your judgment from the LLC.

First, get a writ of execution from the court. This is an official paper that lets you, the creditor, collect your money. Your lawyer can help with this. Unpaid judgments can negatively impact the debtor's credit report, making it harder for them to secure future credit.

Next, find out where the judgment debtor’s assets are. These could be bank accounts or property.

Renewing an Unsatisfied Judgment

If a judgment creditor is unable to collect a judgment within the statute of limitations, they may be able to renew the judgment. The process for renewing a judgment varies by state, but it typically involves filing a request with the court clerk and paying a fee. Renewing a judgment can give the creditor additional time to collect the debt and can also help to maintain the creditor’s priority over other creditors.

It’s essential to note that renewing a judgment does not automatically extend the statute of limitations. The creditor must still take action to collect the debt within the allotted time frame. Additionally, renewing a judgment may not be possible if the debtor has filed for bankruptcy or if the creditor has already collected a portion of the debt.

Role of Court Clerk and Officials

Court officials play a big part in this process. They're like your helpers.

The sheriff, for example, can serve the writ of execution to the judgment debtor on behalf of the creditor. They make sure everything is done by the book.

Bankruptcy courts also come into play if the LLC, as a debtor, files for bankruptcy after losing a lawsuit to a creditor.

Potential Complications

Collecting your judgment from a creditor might not always be smooth sailing though. Sometimes there are bumps in the road. Winning a case in small claims court can also present challenges in collecting the judgment.

For example, if an LLC doesn’t have enough assets to pay off its debts to creditors, it might declare bankruptcy. If that happens, you’ll have to deal with your creditor and go through bankruptcy court to try and get your money back.

Also remember that getting a writ is not an exclusive remedy for a creditor. It’s just one step in collecting what you’re owed.

Navigating the complexities of collecting a judgment from an LLC as a creditor can be challenging. Understanding the legal implications for a creditor, utilizing charging orders, recognizing the personal liability shield of a creditor, enforcing judgments, and taking post-lawsuit steps are crucial to successful judgment collection for a creditor. Expert guidance can be beneficial in these situations.

For more detailed information or professional assistance with your creditor situation, consider consulting with a legal expert. They can provide tailored advice to help you navigate through the creditor process effectively and efficiently, including options to sell judgment to a collection agency if it’s a viable solution for your case.

Debexpert, as an international debt trading platform with expertise in buying and selling debt portfolios, can play a significant role in assisting you with the challenging task of collecting a judgment from an LLC. Here’s how Debexpert can be beneficial in this context:

  1. Access to a Broad Network: Debexpert connects you with a wide network of debt buyers, debt collection agencies, and financial institutions. This network includes entities interested in purchasing judgment debts, which can be particularly useful when dealing with an LLC.
  2. Efficient Matching: The platform uses advanced algorithms to match your judgment debt with potential buyers who specialize in dealing with LLCs. This ensures that your judgment gets in front of the right audience, increasing the chances of a successful sale.
  3. Market Insights: Debexpert provides valuable market insights and data on judgment debt transactions, including those involving LLCs. This information can help you make informed decisions about pricing and negotiation strategies.
  4. Legal Expertise: The platform often collaborates with legal experts who are well-versed in judgment collection from various entities, including LLCs. These experts can offer guidance on the legal aspects of your case.
  5. Streamlined Transactions: Debexpert facilitates the entire transaction process, from listing your judgment debt to finalizing the sale. This streamlines the often complex process of collecting judgments from LLCs.
  6. Competitive Bidding: By presenting your judgment debt to multiple potential buyers, Debexpert allows for competitive bidding, potentially increasing the sale price.
  7. Confidentiality and Security: The platform prioritizes data security and confidentiality, ensuring that sensitive information related to your case is protected.

If you’re seeking to collect a judgment from an LLC, consider taking advantage of Debexpert’s specialized platform. By creating a listing for your judgment, you open the door to a network of potential buyers and industry experts who can assist you in navigating the complexities of judgment collection. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to efficiently recover what you’re owed - get started with Debexpert today!

Impact on Credit History

A court judgment can have a significant impact on a debtor’s credit history. When a creditor obtains a judgment, it is typically reported to the credit bureaus and can remain on the debtor’s credit report for several years. This can make it difficult for the debtor to obtain credit or loans in the future.

If the creditor is able to collect the debt, they must file a satisfaction of judgment with the court clerk. This document notifies the credit bureaus that the debt has been paid and can help to improve the debtor’s credit score. However, if the creditor is unable to collect the debt, the judgment can remain on the debtor’s credit report indefinitely.

In some cases, a debtor may be able to negotiate a settlement with the creditor that includes removing the judgment from their credit report. This can be a beneficial option for debtors who are struggling to pay their debts and want to improve their credit score. However, it’s essential to carefully review any settlement agreement to ensure that it is in the debtor’s best interests.

Category
Written by
Carlos Aispuro
Lender Relationship Director

With thirty years of experience in banking, debt collections, compliance, audit, and governance, I have supported strategic plans and improved customer experiences. I possess hands-on knowledge in crucial C-Suite areas, including developing new policies and procedures, optimizing their models, and exploring new tools to help institutions achieve their goals more effectively.

  • Banking, debt collections, compliance, audit, and governance expert
  • Crucial C-Suite areas expert

What debt are we selling

We specialize in car, real estate, consumer and credit cards loans. We can sell any kind of debt.
Interested in buying or selling debt portfolios?
Let's connect! Fill out this form 👇